Nevada Newsmakers

Fernley leaders react to interview with Brad Crowell

Commentary - July 23, 2021

Editor's note: This response was sent to Nevada Newsmakers from City of Fernley officals in response to an interview done by host Sam Shad with Brad Crowell, the director of the Nevada Department of Conservation and Natural Resources. It is published in its entirety, with minor editing changes.

Fernley is extremely disappointed by the inaccurate information given to the public by Mr. Shad and Mr. Crowell on a recent Nevada Newsmakers broadcast.  If either Mr. Crowell or Mr. Shad had bothered to contact City officials prior to the show we could have provided them accurate data and information about the Truckee Canal and the impacts of the Bureau of Reclamation’s proposed project to line the canal.  Instead, they chose to discuss the project without having researched the facts and thereby misinform the public.   

The reality is that this project will have a devastating impact on Fernley and its 20,000 citizens.  Even the Bureau of Reclamation acknowledges that its project “will hurt people.”  Despite this, Mr. Shad and Mr. Crowell treated Fernley’s concerns as mere minor inconveniences.  This is especially troubling coming from Mr. Crowell who, as a state official, should be looking out for the best interests of the citizens of Nevada rather than promoting a federal government project that will hurt those citizens. 

Other Nevada officials, including Sens. Cortez-Masto and Rosen and U.S. Rep. Amodei, have been supportive of Fernley’s position and are actively working to assist Fernley getting its concerns addressed.  Having Mr. Shad and Mr. Crowell spread misinformation and inaccuracies about Fernley’s situation undermines the bi-partisan efforts of Nevada’s other public officials.      

In Mr. Shad’s initial question to Mr. Crowell (at minute 16:45 on the video) he states that ½ the water diverted through the canal is “lost” to Fernley.  Mr. Shad does not indicate where he got this number.  In reality, scientific studies show that the groundwater recharge from the canal to the Fernley aquifer is estimated at between 12,000 and 18,000 acre-feet/annually.  In an average water year, apx. 200,000 acre-feet of water are diverted from the Truckee River through the canal.  This means that the water “lost” to Fernley is roughly 10% (not ½) of what is being delivered through the canal.

Mr. Shad’s question was also internally inconsistent.  In one breath he claims that the recharge water is “lost”, implying that it is wasted, while at the same time he acknowledges that the citizens of Fernley are using that water.  Under Nevada law, if the water is being beneficially used, it is not being wasted.  Nothing is “lost.”  Instead, the water is being used exactly as was intended when the Newlands Project was built – to support the development and growth of towns and cities along the canal. 

In Mr. Crowell’s response he states that this issue is not in the State’s jurisdiction.  This is incorrect.  In Nevada all water belongs to the public and is managed by the State, including water diverted and used by the Federal government.  The State is the jurisdictional entity that issued Fernley its groundwater permits based on the recharge provided by the canal.  And, the State has always supported and encouraged Fernley’s use of the recharge water. 

Mr. Crowell also acknowledged that he did not have any data about Fernley’s water rights in front of him but then went on to make claims about those rights anyway.  He incorrectly states that Fernley has other water that it can use instead of the recharged groundwater.  However, Fernley is currently 100% dependent on its groundwater rights, over 90% of which comes from the canal recharge. 

Fernley is working to diversify its water resources and will soon be able to bring surface water into its municipal system.  However, the Bureau of Reclamation has placed restrictions on Fernley’s ability to use its surface water for municipal purposes.  One example of this is that the Bureau has restricted Fernley’s use of its surface water to the irrigation season.  But Fernley has to provide water to its citizens on a 24 hour a day, 7 day a week, year-round basis.  This means that Fernley will still be reliant on its groundwater resources.   

In addition, Fernley’s surface water rights were dedicated to the City under agreements with property owners which require Fernley to use the water to support future growth and development.  In other words, those water resources are spoken for and are not available to be used as a replacement for the lost groundwater.

Finally, neither Mr. Shad, nor Mr. Crowell even acknowledged the effect that lining the canal will have on the hundreds of citizens whose homes rely on domestic wells.  Studies show that if the canal is lined over 70% of these wells will fail leaving the homeowners with no other source of water.  Because of the location of these homes, the City does not have the ability to hook them up to the municipal water system.

Read full article




Recent Articles:

Director of NV Division of Conservation & Natural Resources responds to Fernley city leaders
Commentary - July 23, 2021

With respect to the United States Bureau of Reclamation’s (USBOR) proposal to line the Truckee Canal, NDWR understands that there are many challenges and complexities this proposed project creates for the City of Fernley.

Dept. of of Conservation and Natural Resources responds to Fernley's water/canal issues
Commentary - July 23, 2021

In response to the July 28, 2021, letter issued by the City of Fernley, a few key points raised deserve factual clarification.

Thacker Pass lithium mine appears to be better bet than Rhyolite Ridge site, head of NV's Dept. of Conservation & Natural Resources says
News - July 23, 2021

"Lithium, from my perspective, is one of the great emerging economic stories for Nevada that will really be a benefit if we can leverage it correctly. We have a unique ability, compared to other states, to have the full economic lifecycle for lithium, from extraction to production in batteries to recycling it back into the supply chain. And we have all three of those components here." Brad Crowell, Director of the Nevada Department of Conservation and Natural Resources,

'Johnny' Ascuaga remembered as a visionary, clever gaming pioneer who had some great ideas
Commentary - June 30, 2021

Ascuaga, at his essence, was an idea man. And in his time running one of the great resorts in Nevada, he had plenty.

Las Vegas mayor wants apology from CNN's Anderson Cooper for mocking her during interview
News - June 22, 2021

"I think he owes me an apology and I'd love to have it from him." Las Vegas Mayor Carolyn Goodman, speaking about CNN's Anderson Cooper

Nevada GOP should dump state chairman, audit state party operations, Rogich says
News - June 21, 2021

"The first thing they (Nevada Republicans) should do is get rid of their state chairman. He is not capable of running this operation any more. I mean Michael McDonald, primarily." Sig Rogich, current president of the Rogich Communications Group.



Reid defends embattled Nevada Democratic chair, says 'so-called split' in state party is 'exaggerated'
News - June 10, 2021

"Judith Whitmer and the so-called split in the Nevada Democratic Party is exaggerated because there isn't one." Former U.S. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid

Amodei sees a path to victory in 2022 GOP gubernatorial primary; warns Sisolak will be formidable foe in general election
News - May 26, 2021

"It is going to be a tough race. A sitting, incumbent Democratic governor. And that (Nevada Democratic) party has a history. They've handed Donald Trump a 100,000-vote loss in Clark County -- twice." U.S. Rep. Mark Amodei, R-Carson City

LCB needs to be split along party lines, after backing losing side in Supreme Court fight, Sen. Gansert says
News - May 18, 2021

"It was also frustrating because the LCB defended the Democrats' position, which ended up being wrong, right? So we've got the Supreme Court that finds it wrong and then the Republicans, to fight it, had to actually raise money to do that." State Sen. Heidi Gansert, R-Reno, speaking of a legal fight over a bill that raised revenues without a two-thirds majority of lawmakers

Lawmakers need state tour before spending $3 billion for American Rescue Plan, Sen. Ratti says
News - May 17, 2021

"Sixty-three legislators will have lots of ideas. But more importantly, I think we'll want to set up a process so the public can give us their ideas." State Sen. Julia Ratti, D-Sparks

Nevada needs 'crack down' on lucrative black-market marijuana, Judiciary chairman Yeager says
News - May 14, 2021

"I think there has just been a lack of enforcement on the illegal side. And rightfully so. When we have limited resources, it is probably not the No. 1 issue. But I think it is important that the Cannabis Compliance Board should really get into that space and make sure we are trying to crack down on those (black market dealers)." Steve Yeager, Assembly Judiciary chairman

Little girl's memory of death-row meeting with dad may be most emotional testimony of 2021 Legislature, Yeager says
Commentary - May 13, 2021

"What a debate like the death penalty shows you is that, unfortunately, we are human beings and we are capable of doing really awful things to one another." Steven Yeager, chairman, Assembly Judiciary Committee



State has money to pay for Democrats' mistake, if Supreme Court rules in favor of GOP senators, Settelmeyer says
News - May 11, 2021

"It doesn't really create a hole. It just shows that they stole money from people when they didn't have the authority to do so." State Sen. James Settelmeyer, on impact of Senate Republican lawsuit against two revenue bills passed by Democrats in the 2019 Legislature without the constitutionally-mandated two-thirds majority

Spearman, LGBTQ+ champion, pushes ERA, sees current time as 'revelation' on equality for all people
News - May 3, 2021

"We are becoming more aware of the diversity of God's creation. God didn't make all roses. He didn't make all daffodils. He has a bunch of different types of flowers. There are different types of grass, not one type of tree." State Sen. Pat Spearman, D-NLV

Amodei at crossroads: Will he run for governor in 2022 or remain in Congress?
Commentary - April 30, 2021

"You know, I don't know what the 2022 election is going to be like. However, there is a chance you could be in the majority and on Appropriations, which would put you -- I don't know if the retirements (for members of Appropriations Committee) are there yet or not -- but could put you up first for a committee chairmanship. Which you know, is a good place to be in terms of making sure we get policies right and also taking care of Nevada." Rep. Mark Amodei, R-Carson City

Rep. Titus predicts Nevada tourism will come back 'with a vengeance'
News - April 28, 2021

"They (Nevada visitors) just have this pent-up need to be on holiday, go outside, be at Lake Tahoe, hike around the state, come to Las Vegas. So our recovery, I hope and think, will come back pretty rapidly." U.S. Rep. Dina Titus, D-LV

Sexaul harassment lawsuit against Blockchains CEO should be considered seperately from plan to build 'smart city,' Gov. Sisolak's COS says
News - April 22, 2021

"The governor, and our entire office, take any allegation very seriously. The policy, when we think of Innovation Zones in this legislation, is separate from any one individual or business." Michelle White, Gov. Sisolak's chief of staff

Longtime lawmaker Goicoechea sees water fight at Legislature; remains wary of SNWA hold on rural water sources
News - April 9, 2021

"The water in this state belongs to the people in this state and if you end up creating laws and putting it in a position where it can actually be held forever, by an entity, you are going to see the price of water skyrocket." State Sen. Pete Goicoechea, R-Eureka


Next Page Last Page